|
VICTOR HALLETT - THE WESTERN MAIL: |
|
|
"The theatre critic David Adams
has raised some interesting points in these pages about what he
sees as the differences between theatrical theatre and
television theatre. Now surely there can't be anything much
closer to watching television than three people talking directly
to the audience with no more scenery than three chairs on three
rectangles of sand.
Catch London Classic Theatre Company's totally gripping
production on its tour and you'll discover just how
electrifyingly theatrical such a seemingly simple set-up can be.
That's partly to do with the quality of the writing and there is
no one better than writer Brian Friel at grabbing hold of your
attention, making you care about his people and ensuring that
their words keep you desperate to know what's going to happen.
Molly Sweeney, blind at 10
months old, has a chance to regain her sight in her 40s. Her
ophthalmologist, Mr Rice, once internationally renowned but now
stuck back in Ireland, sees a chance to regain his reputation.
Her husband, Frank, sees his chance to help another deserving
cause by introducing her to new worlds. Only Molly isn't sure
that she won't lose more than she'll gain. As each character
continues their own story in their own style, sometimes
seemingly interrupting each other but never, apart from an
occasional hand on shoulder, reacting to each other, we get to
know them very well.
Peter Cadden's Mr Rice
addresses the audience as though lecturing us about one of his
cases, eyes firmly fixed above our heads. Christopher Patrick
Nolan's Frank engages in frantic eye contact around the audience
as he regales us with his tales of (failed) great schemes or
goes into pedantic detail about words he's newly discovered.
This is a wonderfully comic portrait of the sort of man whose
use of the words "interesting" and "fascinating" would in real
life have you fleeing the room.
But it's Marie McCarthy's Molly who's the emotional engine of
the play. Sure in her familiar blind world she makes us truly
understand how limiting it becomes when she is able to see. Her
bubbling, infectious excitements; her fears; her despairs and
above all her quiet final monologue of acceptance draw us into
her world of total vision, even if the vision doesn't match our
reality. She, though blind, sees and perceives; the two men see
but never truly perceive what is around them.
The quality of the writing would make this good television,
although they would insist on several realistic sets. As stark,
spare theatre it becomes something much more than that, a real
emotional journey for characters and audience alike."
"Brian Friel's plays work best
through explicit and disciplined characterisation, and so it was
with Michael Cabot's powerful and absorbing production of Molly
Sweeney. A cast of three on a simple set - each lit in turn to
give their own accounts of unfolding events - left no room for
any lapse in their, or the audience's, concentration. It has the
intensity of a radio play, and, I'm sure, would lose nothing by
being performed as such. The events, simply, are the 'case' of
Molly, blind almost from birth, taken up by her tireless
campaigner of a husband, who persuades a hitherto
internationally famous eye surgeon to restore her sight. Each
has their own agenda in this simple and moving story. Marie
McCarthy is a beautifully still and focussed Molly, fearful and
fascinated by the prospect of seeing. Christopher Patrick Nolan
is the self-absorbed, shallow, husband, utterly convinced of the
rightness of his mission to restore Molly' s sight.
Peter Cadden is the worldly-weary eye surgeon who has fetched
up in this small Irish backwater after his glittering
international career failed along with his marriage. He is
masterly in his ambivalence to Molly's plight, but also unable
to resist the prospect of success vaulting him back to the top.
Christopher Nolan is the perfect agitated foil to his wife's
stillness, and makes a splendid job of articulating his sheer
inability to stick at anything to make it a success.
My favourite is the eponymous heroine wronged by these men.
Marie McCarthy is truly awesome in portraying Molly's long, sad
decline into insanity brought on by being pitchforked into the
harsh realities of the seeing world from her comfortable,
familiar blindness.
This is world class theatre, and the Civic Theatre is to be
congratulated on bringing it to Chelmsford."